Maintaining Character During Bathroom Upgrades

Maintaining Character During Bathroom Upgrades

Blending the Old and the New: A Bathroom Renovation Journey

As a self-proclaimed maximalist at heart, I've always been drawn to the charm and character of historic homes. When my partner, Will, and I stumbled upon our 1800s-era abode, we knew we had found a true gem - one that would require a delicate touch to preserve its timeless elegance while infusing it with modern functionality. And nowhere was this challenge more apparent than in our quest to renovate the home's original bathrooms.

Our house, you see, is a veritable time capsule, boasting not one, not two, but four bathrooms that have been in use since the turn of the 20th century. It was a unicorn of a find, to be sure, but it also presented us with a unique set of obstacles to overcome. How could we breathe new life into these spaces while still honoring the home's rich history and architectural integrity?

Embracing the Past, Planning for the Future

As we dove headfirst into the renovation process, we knew that the key to success would lie in striking a delicate balance between preserving the bathrooms' historic charm and incorporating essential modern upgrades. It was a delicate dance, to be sure, but one that we were determined to master.

Our research led us down a rabbit hole of discoveries, from the rich history of plumbing in our home to the unique challenges posed by preserving century-old tile and plaster. But with each new obstacle came a sense of renewed purpose, a drive to uncover creative solutions that would honor the past while ensuring the long-term functionality and comfort of our bathrooms.

One of the first decisions we faced was how to approach the tile and plaster situation. While the original 1900s tiles were a sight to behold, the walls above them were in need of some serious attention. After much deliberation, we decided to tile directly over the existing plaster, applying a waterproof membrane to ensure the integrity of the historic tiles. It was a risky move, to be sure, but one that has paid off handsomely, with the new tiles seamlessly blending in with the old and providing a sturdy, water-resistant surface.

Embracing the Unexpected

As we delved deeper into the renovation, we encountered a few curveballs that truly tested our problem-solving skills. The most daunting of these challenges? Tackling the shower plumbing.

Given the centralized nature of our bathroom's layout, running the pipes through the walls would have placed them on an exterior wall - a recipe for disaster in our chilly Northeast climate. Instead, we opted for an exterior-mounted approach, a decision that came with its own set of aesthetic considerations.

After scouring the internet for solutions, we finally landed on the perfect compromise: nickel-plated pipes that would not only blend seamlessly with the historic fixtures but also add a touch of industrial-chic flair to the space.

And then there was the matter of the antique sink - a true gem from the J.L. Mott Ironworks, circa 1900. While its vintage charm was undeniable, the sink's quirky plumbing mechanism had us scratching our heads for weeks on end. Should we upgrade to a modern faucet with a mixer, or stick with the original hot and cold taps? In the end, we decided to preserve the sink's historic integrity, even going so far as to have the stopper mechanism custom-fabricated to ensure its continued functionality.

Striking a Balance: Marrying Old and New

As we navigated the countless decisions and challenges that arose during the renovation process, one guiding principle remained constant: respecting the home's history while infusing it with modern functionality and style.

We took cues from the architectural era in which our home was built, incorporating elements like ornate fixtures, intricate tilework, and a clawfoot bathtub to capture the spirit of the Victorian era. But we also made sure to seamlessly blend these historic touches with contemporary upgrades, such as energy-efficient lighting, hidden storage solutions, and a state-of-the-art exhaust fan to maintain a comfortable, well-ventilated environment.

The result? A bathroom that feels like a harmonious fusion of past and present, a space that honours the home's storied past while catering to the needs of modern living. And as I step into the shower, surrounded by the warm glow of matte black sconces and the gentle flutter of lace curtains, I can't help but feel a sense of pride and accomplishment. We've done it - we've preserved the character of our historic home while breathing new life into one of its most essential spaces.

The Devil's in the Details

Of course, no historic renovation is complete without a healthy dose of personalization and attention to detail. As a self-professed maximalist, I couldn't resist the urge to curate a truly one-of-a-kind gallery wall behind the toilet, a veritable salon of vintage art pieces that lend an air of collected charm to the space.

And when it came to the textiles and accessories, I pulled out all the stops. A handmade linen curtain with pom-pom trim, a vintage rug that adds a touch of warmth and texture, and custom-sewn shower curtains in a historic floral pattern - every element was carefully selected to enhance the bathroom's timeless ambiance.

But perhaps the crowning jewel of our renovation is the marble-topped radiator, a serendipitous find from a local antique store that not only provides a functional surface for displaying small trinkets but also serves as a stunning focal point, seamlessly blending the old and the new.

A Labor of Love, and a Lesson in Patience

Renovating a historic bathroom is no easy feat, and our journey was certainly not without its fair share of challenges and setbacks. But as we stand back and admire the final result, we can't help but feel a deep sense of pride and accomplishment.

This project has been a true labor of love, one that has tested our problem-solving skills, our attention to detail, and our commitment to preserving the character of our beloved home. And while there were moments when we wondered if we had bitten off more than we could chew, the end result has made it all worthwhile.

Now, as we turn our sights to the next phase of our renovation journey - tackling the bedroom - we know that we are armed with a wealth of knowledge and a renewed appreciation for the art of blending the old and the new. After all, isn't that the true essence of historic home ownership - a delicate dance between respect for the past and a vision for the future?

iLIVINGHOME logo white

Quality flooring is the key to a healthy home. That’s why we at i Living Home provide you with only the best.

Contact Info


Sign up for our newsletter to get access to exclusive offers and deals that won’t show up on our website! You’ll also receive tips on how to maintain your flooring for a lifetime of enjoyment!

Flooring Services 

Copyright © 2022. All rights reserved.