Blending Old and New Sections of Your Home

Blending Old and New Sections of Your Home

Mixing the Old and the New: A Harmonious Approach

When it comes to home renovations, the challenge of seamlessly integrating new elements with existing ones can seem daunting. But fear not, my fellow homeowners - I've got a story for you that will change your perspective and inspire you to embrace the art of blending old and new.

Let me take you on a journey to a vacation rental I recently stayed at, nestled in the picturesque town of Nelson, British Columbia. As I stepped into this home, I was immediately captivated by the smooth transition between the old hardwood floors in the bedrooms and hallways, and the brand-new luxury vinyl plank (LVP) flooring in the kitchen and living room. It was so seamless that I didn't even notice the difference until the next day.

Maria Killam's experience with this vacation rental was a game-changer for her opinion on matching new LVP to existing hardwood floors. She had previously been adamant that it couldn't be done, citing the numerous "bad flooring transitions" she had encountered. But this particular home proved her wrong in the most delightful way.

The Key to a Flawless Transition

So, what made this blending of old and new so successful? According to Maria, it all comes down to the careful consideration of the "graining pattern and colour" of the floors. The homeowner who renovated this vacation rental clearly put in the effort to find an LVP that closely matched the existing hardwood, creating a harmonious and almost undetectable transition.

Now, I know what you're thinking - "But I thought matching new LVP to old hardwood was a big no-no?" And you'd be right, in most cases. As Maria explains, the typical scenario involves a "bad flooring transition" that immediately catches the eye and ruins the overall aesthetic.

However, this vacation rental proved that with the right approach, it's possible to achieve a seamless blend. The key is to focus on finding an LVP that closely mimics the color, grain, and even the plank width of your existing hardwood. It may take a bit more time and effort, but the payoff is worth it.

Avoiding the Pitfalls of Mismatched Flooring

Now, let's talk about what not to do when it comes to blending old and new flooring. The vacation rental I stayed at had an unfortunate example of this - the entry foyer had been updated with a grey "farmhouse-style" floor, which clashed horribly with the warm-toned hardwood in the rest of the home.

As Maria so eloquently puts it, the mantra to keep in mind is: "Will this look like it was all installed at the same time?" If the answer is no, then it's time to go back to the drawing board. Mixing and matching disparate flooring styles, colors, and textures is a surefire way to end up with a disjointed and unsatisfying result.

The lesson here is clear: if you're going to introduce new flooring into a space that already has existing hardwood, you need to be meticulous in your selection process. Avoid the temptation of grabbing the first option that catches your eye at the big-box store. Instead, take the time to find the perfect match, even if it means a little extra legwork.

The Value of Patience and Planning

Speaking of legwork, let's talk about the importance of planning and patience when it comes to home renovations. As Maria's story about the vacation rental illustrates, sometimes the best solution may not be the most obvious or convenient one.

The homeowner in this case could have opted for a quick and easy fix, like the grey farmhouse floors in the entry. But instead, they took the time to find an LVP that seamlessly blended with the existing hardwood, creating a cohesive and visually stunning result.

"Trouble now is better than trouble later after the flooring is installed and you realize you made a mistake." - Maria Killam

This sentiment is one that all homeowners should keep in mind. It's tempting to rush into a renovation and go with the first option that seems to work. But as Maria wisely points out, that's a recipe for long-term dissatisfaction. By taking the time to carefully consider your options and plan ahead, you can avoid costly mistakes and end up with a renovation you'll truly love.

Embracing the Charm of Imperfection

Now, I know what you're thinking - "But what if I can't find an exact match for my hardwood floors?" Well, let me tell you, there's still hope. In fact, the vacation rental I stayed at had a slightly different approach that, in my opinion, added to the charm of the space.

The entry foyer, with its grey farmhouse-style floors, didn't quite match the warm-toned hardwood in the rest of the home. But you know what? It didn't matter. The subtle contrast actually added character and interest to the space, creating a sense of intentional design rather than a haphazard mismatch.

As one commenter on the Fine Homebuilding forum so eloquently put it, "When you're adding old to new, it's rare that things will ever look exactly perfect. BUT you can certainly work really hard to make sure that the only person who will ever notice is YOU."

So, if you can't find that elusive perfect match, don't fret. Sometimes, embracing the slight differences between old and new can create a charming and unique aesthetic that adds to the character of your home. The key is to ensure that the overall transition is cohesive and intentional, even if it's not a perfect match.

The Timeless Allure of Hardwood

Now, I know that LVP has become the darling of the flooring world, with its easy maintenance and water-resistant properties. And I can certainly see the appeal, especially for high-traffic areas like kitchens and bathrooms. But when it comes to the overall aesthetic of my home, my heart will always belong to the timeless beauty of hardwood.

There's just something about the warm, natural grain of wood that sets my soul at ease. And as one homeowner on the Mix and Match Design blog so aptly put it, "Either way it's all hardwood or no hardwood. Thats my opinion and I'm sticking to it."

Now, I know that hardwood isn't always the most practical choice, especially in high-moisture areas. But if you have the opportunity to incorporate it into your home, I highly recommend exploring the options. And if you do need to introduce new flooring that doesn't match your existing hardwood, take a page from the vacation rental's playbook and be meticulous in your search for the perfect match.

The Beauty of a Cohesive Home

At the end of the day, the goal when blending old and new in your home should be to create a seamless and cohesive aesthetic. Whether that means finding the perfect LVP match or embracing the charm of purposeful contrasts, the key is to approach the task with intentionality and an eye for detail.

As I sit here, reflecting on my experience in that vacation rental, I can't help but feel inspired. The homeowners could have taken the easy way out, but instead, they put in the effort to create a truly stunning and harmonious space. And that, my friends, is the essence of a well-designed home - one where the old and the new coexist in perfect harmony.

So, the next time you find yourself facing the challenge of blending old and new in your own home, remember the lessons of that vacation rental. Take your time, do your research, and don't be afraid to think outside the box. With a little creativity and a lot of patience, you too can create a space that seamlessly blends the past and the present, leaving your guests (and yourself) in awe.

Now, if you'll excuse me, I'm off to start planning my own home renovation. Who knows, maybe I'll even find a way to incorporate some of that charming old hardwood into the mix. Wish me luck!

iLIVINGHOME logo white

Quality flooring is the key to a healthy home. That’s why we at i Living Home provide you with only the best.

Contact Info


Sign up for our newsletter to get access to exclusive offers and deals that won’t show up on our website! You’ll also receive tips on how to maintain your flooring for a lifetime of enjoyment!

Flooring Services 

Copyright © 2022. All rights reserved.